Friday, March 02, 2012

John Sickels: 2012 Dodgers Top 20 Prospects

  1. Zach Lee, RHP, Grade B+ (按: '11 Grade B)
  2. Nate Eovaldi, RHP, Grade B, Borderline B+ ('09 C, '10 C+, '11 others)
  3. Allen Webster, RHP, Grade B ('09 nil '10 C+ '11 B-)
  4. Garrett Gould, RHP, Grade B ('10 B-, 11 C+)
  5. Alfredo Silverio, OF, Grade B-, borderline B ('06~10 nil, '11 others)
  6. Chris Reed, LHP, Grade B-, borderline B (新人)
  7. Josh Lindblom, RHP, Grade B- ('09 B-, '10B, '11 others)
  8. Chris Withrow, RHP, Grade B- ('08 B-, '09 C+, '10 B+, 11 B-)
  9. Joc Pederson, OF, Grade B- ('11 Others)
  10. Angel Sanchez, RHP, Grade B- (新人)
  11. Gorman Erickson, C, Grade C+ ('06'07~11 nil)
  12. Angelo Songco, 1B-OF, Grade C+ ('10~11 others)
  13. Blake Smith, OF, Grade C+ ('10 nil, '11 others)
  14. Shawn Tolleson, RHP, Grade C+ ('11 others)
  15. Aaron Miller, LHP, Grade C+ ('10 B, '11 B-)
  16. Alex Castellanos, OF-INF, Grade C+ (trade from STL)
  17. Scott Van Slyke, OF-1B, Grade C+ ('06~09 nil, '10 others, '11 nil)
  18. Jonathan Garcia, OF, Grade C+ ('10 nil, '11 C)
  19. Steve Ames, RHP, Grade C+ ('10~11 others)
  20. Jake Lemmerman, SS, Grade C+ ('11 C)

OTHERS: Michael Antonini, LHP; James Baldwin, OF; Logan Bawcom, RHP; Justin Boudreaux, SS: Ralston Cash, RHP; O'Koyea Dickson, 1B; Eric Eadington, LHP; Tim Federowicz, C; Stephen Fife, RHP; Leon Landry, OF; Ethan Martin, RHP; Pratt Maynard, C; Scott McGough, RHP; Chris O'Brien, C; Ryan O'Sullivan, RHP; Red Patterson, RHP (a sleeper); Juan Rodriguez, RHP; Kyle Russell, OF; Alex Santana, 3B; Scott Schebler, OF; Josh Wall, RHP.

Sickels認為Dodgers農場普通但並不差。有很多有一些可能成為輪值中段右手及兩隻左手。也提到可能給Red Patterson C+的評價。

但打者方面就不太好,低階一些很有tools的,與一些很有power但沒長眼睛的。捕手方面,Sickels反給Gorman Erickson超過Tim Federowicz的評價。

2 comments:

ako said...

Gorman Erickson, C, Grade C+ ('06~11 nil)

這個好銷魂 XD

madboy said...

其實你抓到bug了,Erickson '06年選秀第15輪,'07年才打第一季,理論上'07年Sickels才會有對他的評價,我寫錯了,應該是('07~11 nil)才對...

不過話說回來這也是因為近年來Sickels的top 20 prospects評價排行多了個others這垃圾坑可以填一堆人名的關係,古早的排行可沒有這麼詳細,不然這名單上others的部份通通都變成nil,那應該很多突然一年爆發的prospects應該都一直被列在nil吧?

倒是下面這兩隻常駐在nil裡我滿訝異的...

5. Alfredo Silverio, OF, Grade B- ('06~10 nil, '11 others)
一直很受球探派(BA系)重視的Silverio,之前竟然因為打不好沒被Sickels列進來過...

16. Scott Van Slyke, OF-1B, Grade C+ ('06~09 nil, '10 others, '11 nil)
血統好但也是一直打不好,近年兩度大爆發('09 & '11)後才被Sickels列進來。